Susan Banghart - WriterArtist
  • Home
  • About
  • Art
  • Writing
  • Blog

Writer Needs Cape

10/10/2011

3 Comments

 
Picture
That's a rain tree in bloom. In another couple weeks the yellow blossoms will morph into papery rose-colored seed pods, followed by an invasion of rain tree, seed-loving insects called Jadera bugs or soapberry bugs.  The rain trees' brilliant show is one more sign Florida's easing out of summer.

But I digress. I should be writing about my mentorship. Correction. I should be working on the second hundred pages  of my novel. I'd like to blame this lethargy on Monday. Truth is, I'm tiptoeing around my writer self, leery of undoing the flimsy bandaid that's holding her together.

Caroline Leavitt responded to the first ninety pages of my book with constructive criticism and a dollop of praise. She asked questions that drove me deeper into the story, addressed weaknesses in the plot and undeveloped characters, and encouraged me to ask questions. I digested the review and a few days later I responded to Caroline with more questions and some clarifying notes about plot and character motivation. So far, so good. Sure, hearing I started the story too early (meaning chapters one and two were trash) hurt. But I was feeling challenged and motivated and the story was growing.

Then, I got Caroline's response to my response. She liked some of the new plotlines and character development and she says this is a great story . . . at heart.  Who doesn't want to hear their story's great? It's the caveat that worried me. That along with the rest of the comments that felt like they wiped out the other eight chapters I sent. It's amazing how fast the thrill of seeing ninety pages in print turns into the agony of imagining them shredded. I spent four days in a torrent, my brain spinning around and around the issues with no results. Yesterday, my brain shut down and I'm leaving it be. In the meantime, my story's stopped and I wonder, was this mentorship a mistake? Maybe I'm not ready for this level of criticism. I've only been writing for four years and my education's spotty. Maybe, I don't know enough to understand what Caroline's trying to teach me.

Trusting someone you've only just met with your book is hard. No matter how much you respect the person who recommended them and how shiny their credentials. When they ask you to put aside your doubts and believe in their instincts, it feels like jumping without a parachute. If their advice conflicts with what you've learned, you need a super hero's courage to jump from the plane. I've never worn a cape. Right now, I'm hiding in the bowels of the aircraft where no one can find me.

3 Comments
 

    Author

    I'm a children's writer, climbing the mountain to publication, and hoping the editor at the top opens the door.

    Archives

    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    Categories

    All
    2012
    Book Art
    Caroline Leavitt
    Childhood Friendship
    Children's Holiday Books
    Children's Movies
    Children's Writers
    Children's Writing
    Children's Writing
    Creating
    Criticism
    Critique Groups
    Dummy Books
    Dystopian Books
    E Books
    Eckerd College Writers In Paradise Conference
    Fantasy Fiction
    Harry Potter
    Imagination
    J.K. Rowling
    Julianna Baggott
    Kidlitart
    Kim Wright
    Kindle
    Library Downloads
    Maggie Stiefvater
    Motivation
    Nanowrimo
    New Year
    Novels
    Picture Books
    Post Apocalyptic Books
    Publishing
    Pure
    Resolutions
    Revision
    Scbwi
    Spring Fever
    Stories
    Story Ideas
    Trilogies
    Ucla Writing Classes
    Verla Kay
    Writers
    Writer's Block
    Writing
    Writing For Children
    Writing. Writers
    Ya Books
    Ya Novels

    Blogroll
    Baggott, Asher & Bode
    Picture This!
    The Bookshelf Muse
    Kidlitosphere

    Helpful Links
    Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators
    Agent Query
    Verla Kay

    DiCamillo on Writing

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Bloggers - Meet Millions of Bloggers
    Click to set custom HTML

Copyright Susan Banghart 2011-2012

Create a free website with Weebly